Site last updated: Friday, March 29, 2024

Log In

Reset Password
MENU
Butler County's great daily newspaper

District attorney pulls back offer of lie detector test

Butler County District Attorney Richard Goldinger has nixed a deal reached between one of his assistants and the attorney for a man accused of child molestation at the day care center that his wife operates.

The deal was for defendant Roger L. Young, 65, of Oakland Township to take a polygraph test with the results to determine if the case against him should proceed or be dropped.

“I am not going to honor the agreement made at (Tuesday’s) preliminary hearing,” Goldinger said this morning. “I had no idea it was made, and I wasn’t consulted about it or asked if it was acceptable to me.”

Goldinger’s decision means the preliminary hearing for Young is back on. A new date was not immediately set.

State police have accused Young of inappropriately touching two girls, ages 3 and 4, at the Patti Cake Child Care Center in 2010.

He is charged with two felony counts of corruption of minors and two misdemeanor counts of indecent assault.

Young’s hearing, which was set for Tuesday at the office of District Judge Lewis Stoughton in Chicora, was continued after attorneys for both sides agreed to the unusual deal.

Russ Karl, county assistant district attorney, later discussed the deal which he acknowledged that he initially proposed to Young’s attorney, Michael Zunder.

“If (Young) passes the polygraph, the charges will be withdrawn,” Karl said. “If he fails, he waives the charges to court.”

“The agreement is not appropriate and doesn’t achieve justice for the victims in the alleged crime,” Goldinger said.

During their investigation, police reviewed video surveillance from the day care that showed Young assaulting the girls, according to court documents.

Goldinger said he first learned of Tuesday’s deal about 9 a.m. Wednesday, while speaking to a representative of the crime victim’s advocate office.

He said he was immediately troubled by the agreement and later that day met with the investigating trooper to review the facts of the case.

“That convinced me that I wasn’t going to honor the agreement,” Goldinger said.

He eventually met with Karl.

“(Karl) explained to me why he did what he did,” Goldinger said. He declined to disclose details of their conversation.

Goldinger told Karl of his decision to quash the deal. He then notified Zunder of his decision.

While Goldinger said his assistants have “some latitude” to make deals at the preliminary level, in more serious cases, he expects to be consulted.

More in Digital Media Exclusive

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS