Karns City's Trevor Geibel gets around Moniteau in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Karns City's Braden Slater avoids a Moniteau tackle during a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Karns City's Marching Band celebrates the team's victory against Moniteau in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Karns City's Hunter Scherer avoids a block from Moniteau in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Karns City's Hunter Scherer avoids a block from Moniteau in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Karns City football coach Joe Sherwin huddles with the team after their victory against Moniteau in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Karns City's Mason Bell, left, and Cam Ealy work together to get past Moniteau in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Moniteau High School's marching band and dance team perform at half time in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Moniteau's Brendin Sankey is tackled in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Moniteau gets into formation during a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Moniteau High School's marching band and dance team perform at half time in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Moniteau High School's marching band and dance team perform at half time in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Moniteau High School's marching band and dance team perform at half time in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Moniteau High School's marching band and dance team perform at half time in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Karns City's Cole Johnston avoid a tackle during a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Karns City's Hunter Scherer falls during a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Karns City's Braden Slater is tackled in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Karns City's Quinn Robinson, back, and Mason MacTaggart celebrate a block during a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Karns City's Hunter Scherer runs the ball in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Karns City's Hunter Scherer runs a play in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Karns City's Braden Slater brings the ball to the end zone during a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Karns City's Cam Ealy, left, and Riley Hamilton celebrate a touchdown in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Karns City tackles Moniteau during a PIAA high school football season opener at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Karns City High School's marching band and performs at half time in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Karns City's Quinn Robinson, left, and Mason MacTaggart celebrate a block during a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
Attendees of a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools participate in a moment of silence for Mason Martin ahead of the game at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Karns City's Trevor Geibel gets around Moniteau in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Karns City's Braden Slater avoids a Moniteau tackle during a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Karns City's Marching Band celebrates the team's victory against Moniteau in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Karns City's Hunter Scherer avoids a block from Moniteau in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Karns City's Hunter Scherer avoids a block from Moniteau in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Karns City football coach Joe Sherwin huddles with the team after their victory against Moniteau in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Karns City's Mason Bell, left, and Cam Ealy work together to get past Moniteau in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Moniteau High School's marching band and dance team perform at half time in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Moniteau's Brendin Sankey is tackled in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Moniteau gets into formation during a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Moniteau High School's marching band and dance team perform at half time in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Moniteau High School's marching band and dance team perform at half time in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Moniteau High School's marching band and dance team perform at half time in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Moniteau High School's marching band and dance team perform at half time in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Karns City's Cole Johnston avoid a tackle during a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Karns City's Hunter Scherer falls during a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Karns City's Braden Slater is tackled in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Karns City's Quinn Robinson, back, and Mason MacTaggart celebrate a block during a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Karns City's Hunter Scherer runs the ball in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Karns City's Hunter Scherer runs a play in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Karns City's Braden Slater brings the ball to the end zone during a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Karns City's Cam Ealy, left, and Riley Hamilton celebrate a touchdown in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Karns City tackles Moniteau during a PIAA high school football season opener at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Karns City High School's marching band and performs at half time in a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Karns City's Quinn Robinson, left, and Mason MacTaggart celebrate a block during a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
-
Attendees of a PIAA high school football season opener between Karns City and Moniteau High Schools participate in a moment of silence for Mason Martin ahead of the game at Karns City High School on Friday, August 23. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle (8/23/2024)
KARNS CITY — Numbers never lie.
On Friday night at Diehl Stadium, they were brutally honest.
In a 59-0 home romp over neighboring Moniteau, Karns City (1-0) snapped the football just nine times in its own territory. The Warriors (0-1) never crossed midfield or even gained a first down.
“They beat us up front — really, they beat us all over the place tonight,” Moniteau coach Bob Rottman said. “I didn’t expect it. I thought our kids would play a little better tonight. … We need to play with more heart.”
The Warriors had as many plays that ended in a positive gain in the first half (five) as the Gremlins had touchdowns in that same span. Moniteau finished the season-opening contest with negative-31 yards.
Karns City's Hunter Scherer runs over a Moniteau defender in a PIAA high school football season opener at Karns City High School on Friday, Aug. 23, 2024. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle
Related Article: PIAA high school football 2024: Scores, news, photos and more from Week 1 around Butler County
Related Article: PA high school football 2024: Butler County team previews, top players and fall sports breakdowns
“That’s pretty much where every game starts is up front,” said Karns City coach Joe Sherwin, whose team is 7-0 against the Warriors since 2019. “If you’re able to win the line of scrimmage, good things happen. I think we were able to control both sides of the line of scrimmage tonight.”
The contest’s first five plays from scrimmage began on Karns City’s half. After an 11-yard Scherer run put the Gremlins past the midway mark, the ball wasn’t snapped on his side’s turf until a third-quarter Trent Beachem punt was downed at Karns City’s 36.
Scherer punctuated that game-opening, 10-play, 79-yard march with a bruising 6-yard surge. On the other side of the ball, he made a switch from linebacker to defensive tackle.
“We came in here wanting to control the ball, and we did pretty successfully,” Scherer said. “We played our game tonight.”
Karns City's Trevor Geibel gets around a Moniteau defender in a PIAA high school football season opener at Karns City High School on Friday, Aug. 23, 2024. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle
Warriors signal-caller Brendin Sankey was intercepted on his team’s second play from scrimmage, setting up a Mason Bell ground score six snaps later. Moniteau had five three-and-outs. Their other series ended in a fumble and a late turnover on downs.
“It really all came down to the defensive line,” Sherwin said. “They controlled the line of scrimmage. They made a lot of the tackles themselves — linebackers, defensive backs didn’t really have to make as many.”
The Gremlins wound up with 324 yards rushing, and 16 different players registered at least one carry, with Scherer leading the pack with 59 yards.
Related Article: Karns City football 2024 preview: What to watch, 3 things to know and schedule
Related Article: Moniteau football 2024 preview: What to watch, 3 things to know and schedule
Braden Slater also scored on the ground in the initial half before entering halftime ahead by 38. Trevor Geibel and Mason MacTaggart punched it in during the victory, too.
“If you control the line of scrimmage offensively and defensively, (it’s) how you win games,” said Bell, who also contributed two sacks and a pair of extra points after kicker Braden Slater exited the game with leg cramps.
Karns City quarterback Cole Johnston threw air strikes to Troy Nagel, Brennan Harmon and Riley Hamilton.
Karns City's Quinn Robinson, left, and Mason MacTaggart celebrate a block during a PIAA high school football season opener against Moniteau at Karns City High School on Friday, Aug. 23, 2024. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle
Moniteau 0 0 0 0 — 0
Karns City 21 17 7 14 — 59
First Quarter
KC — Hunter Scherer 6 run (Braden Slater kick), 6:57
KC — Mason Bell 6 run (Slater kick), 3:15
KC — Troy Nagel 33 pass from Cole Johnston (Slater kick), 0:21
Second Quarter
KC — Braden Slater 1 run (Slater kick), 6:21
KC — Brennan Harmon 14 pass from Johnston (Slater kick), 4:28
KC – Braden Slater 17 field goal, 2:05
Third Quarter
KC — Riley Hamilton 12 pass from Johnston (Slater kick), 7:53
Fourth Quarter
KC — Trevor Geibel 3 run (Mason Bell kick), 8:10
KC — Mason MacTaggart 10 run (Bell kick), 3:10
Individual Statistics
Rushing: Karns City, Hunter Scherer 8-59, Owen Heginbotham 4-57, Braden Slater 5-48, Cole Johnston 5-40, Trevor Geibel 4-27, Mason MacTaggart 2-17, Riley Hamilton 1-14, Ronald Sczcgiel 3-14, Bradden Hamilton 1-12, Nathan Hess 2-8, Quinn Robinson 2-8, Mason Bell 1-6, Owen Kaufman 2-6, Bodey Anderson 2-5, Trevor Mong 2-3, Bryce Galan 1-0. Moniteau, Cole Scott 3-3, Levi Lacava 1-1, Aiden Shakley 1-0, Jesse Kohlmeyer 3-(-2), Jake Long 1-(-6), Brendin Sankey 7-(-27). Totals: 13-(-31).
Passing: Karns City, Cole Johnston 7-11-89-0, Trevor Geibel 1-1-10-0. Moniteau, Brendin Sankey 1-7-2-1, Jake Long 1-2-(-2)-0.
Receiving: Karns City, Troy Nagel 1-33, Riley Hamilton 3-31, Brennan Harmon 1-14, Owen Kaufman 1-10, Braden Slater 1-10, Hunter Scherer 1-1. Moniteau, Cole Scott 1-2, Jesse Kohlmeyer 1-(-2).