BUTLER TWP — Butler football didn’t run out of effort. It did run out of time.

Two fourth-quarter touchdowns by the Golden Tornado cut into a 20-point deficit, but Shaler held on for a 20-14 victory in Friday night’s season opener at Art Bernardi Stadium.

“The effort was there. Mistakes hurt us earlier,” Butler coach Eric Christy said.

Butler trailed 20-0 early in the fourth quarter and faced a third-and-8 at its own 27-yard line. Jacob Kollinger took a handoff, broke free off-tackle and rambled 73 yards for the Tornado’s first score of the night.

Related Article: PA high school football 2024: Butler County team previews, top players and fall sports breakdowns Related Article: PIAA high school football 2024: Scores, news, photos and more from Week 1 around Butler County

After Shaler went three-and-out, the Tornado threatened again. A mishandled snap on first down from the Titans’ 11 resulted in a 12-yard loss, however, and quarterback Alec Teff’s pass into the end zone on fourth down from the 11 was intercepted by Joe Rispoli.

Butler got the ball back one more time, driving 67 yards in nine plays, Ethan Deless scored on a 6-yard run, but only 47 seconds remained. Shaler easily received the ensuing onside kick, and the issue was decided.

“We began to cramp late in the game,” Shaler coach Jim Ryan said. “Guys were caught out of position. ... We got out of here with a win. That’s the important thing, but, no, not the way we wanted to finish.”

The Titans had a 3-0 lead at halftime as Riley Douglas booted a 35-yard field goal with 4:21 left in the half. The Tornado missed a pair of scoring opportunities in the opening half, turning the ball over on downs at the Shaler 14 early in the second period and inside the 5 following a completed pass as time expired in the half.

Nicholas Baggetta’s interception — returning the ball inside the Shaler 15 — set up the first opportunity.

Christy stayed away from field goal attempts on both occasions.

“That phase of our game just isn’t there yet,” he said. “I felt our chances were better to try to stick the ball in the end zone.

“We moved the ball well tonight. We showed a lot of promise. Again, mistakes are what hurt us.”

Related Article: Butler football 2024 preview: What to watch, 3 things to know and schedule Related Article: QB Alec Teff revamped his game after season-ending injury. Now he’s ready to lead Butler football

Butler mistakes in the punt game set up a pair of Titan scores in the third quarter. Baggetta was forced to throw the ball away before he could punt early in the third quarter. Shaler put together a 29-yard scoring drive as a result, capped by Rispoli’s 1-yard run. Rispoli had 15 carries for 115 yards on the night.

The Tornado fumbled away a punt inside their 15 late in the quarter, setting up a 36-yard Douglas field goal.

Rispoli threw 10 passes in the first half before becoming a fixture in Shaler’s power running game the rest of the night.

“We knew we had that in our back pocket and it worked for us,” Ryan said of the ground game.

Teff, injured most of last season, threw for 188 yards. Kollinger ran for 128, and Preston Simko caught nine passes for 102 yards.

“Our offensive line was great. I was hardly touched tonight,” Teff said. “Everybody gave 100% for four quarters, right to the end. I’m excited about what our team can do.”

Butler hosts Brashear at 7 p.m. next Friday.

Shaler 0 3 10 7 — 20

Butler 0 0 0 14 — 14

Second Quarter

S — Riley Douglas 25 field goal, 4:21

Third Quarter

S — Joe Rispoli 1 run (Douglas kick), 5:40

S — Douglas 29 field goal, :36

Fourth Quarter

S — Rispoli 41 run (Douglas kick), 11:39

B — Jacob Kollinger 73 run (Alex Fulmer kick), 10:37

B — Ethan Deless 6 run (Fulmer kick), :47

Individual Statistics

Passing — Shaler, Joe Rispoli 4-10-43-1, Max Wiley 1-3-2-0. Butler, Alec Teff 21-41-188-1.

Rushing — Shaler, Joe Rispoli 15-115, Isaac McKay 3-4, Braylon Ronel 10-7, Jayden Conrad 3-12, Aaron Aversa 1-5. Butler, Mark Klemz -33, TEAM 3-(-30), Evan Reinsel 2-3, Jacob Kollinger 9-128, Ethan Deless 1-6.

Receiving — Shaler, Isaac McKay 1-6, Aaron Aversa 1-10, Luke Glaser 1-21, Jonathan Saban 1-6, Braylon Ronel 1-2. Butler, Jacob Kollinger 1-3, Mark Klemz 7-59, Marcus Vicari 1-7, Preston Simko 9-102, Leland Anderson 1-(-8), Quinlan Hanley 2-15.