The Butler Eagle began awarding its scoring trophy in 1990, given to the high school football player who scored the most points in the county each season.

Here is the complete list of every Eagle Scoring Trophy winner:

Year Winner (School) Points

1990 Brian Kurn (Freeport) 104

1991 Ron DeJidas (Freeport) 114

1992 Ron DeJidas (Freeport) 158

1993 Rick Belles (Karns City) 80

1994 Cory Hooks (Union) 118

1995 Jeremy Scherer (Karns City) 84

1996 Jason Hackwelder (A-C Valley) 132

1997 Steve Spiker (A-C Valley) 124

1998 Mike Leach (A-C Valley) 146

1999 Mike Leach (A-C Valley) 198

2000 Josh Kniess (Slippery Rock) 192

2001 Billy Graham (Karns City) 186

2002 Matt Carnahan (Karns City) 152

2003 Josh Fiscus (Karns City) and

Travis Sarver (Slippery Rock) 116

2004 Josh Fiscus (Karns City) 94

2005 Paul Ferrese (Mars) 96

2006 Bill Bair (Mars) 150

2007 Bill Bair (Mars) 204

2008 Jono Powell (Slippery Rock) 102

2009 James Shope (Moniteau) 136

2010 Wes Phipps (Grove City) 114

2011 Wes Phipps (Grove City) 144

2012 Forrest Barnes (Seneca Valley) 152

2013 Josh Schultheis (Mars) 132

2014 Jerome Turner (North Catholic) 140

2015 Isaiah Johnson (Mars) 108

2016 Isaiah Johnson (Mars) and Kaiden Powers (Karns City) 132

2017 Dalton Beham (Karns City) 120

2018 Garrett Reinke (Mars) 132

2019 Teddy Ruffner (Mars) 152

2020 Teddy Ruffner (Mars) 144

2021 Luke Garing (Karns City) 140

2022 Ben Lane (Freeport) 114

2023 Evan Wright (Mars) 182

2024 Braden Slater (Karns City) 163